Critique 17

Posted on April 25th, by Snake in Critique. 1 Comment

Critique 17


A friend of mine asked me if I could take this image and just crop it down to what would look good.  This is a hard thing to do sometimes, when it’s your image. I find it very difficult, sometimes to crop or alter photos that I have taken, because I have so much emotional connection to them. I often times will go out on a photo trip, then let the images sit on the hard drive for weeks or months at a time. Mainly so I disconnect myself with what I was experiencing when I made the image. I am getting better, I can now brutally purge images soon after I take them. So when my friend asked me to edit this, I completely understood. He didn’t set out to make this image, he liked the sunset and heard over his shoulder this set of geese flying in. He grabbed a different lens and popped off a burst to try and get something. I wish my luck was as good ;)

I took the image, cropped it down, added a ND filter from left to right and darkened that half of the image first, then a ND filter from right to left to lighten up the geese.

One Response to “Critique 17”

  1. Jim Begley says:

    BTW, I really like the new look. Clean and Simple.
    Great info on the crop and the ND tricks….

Leave a Reply

The Critiques

Thank you to all who have submitted images.

Critique 50

This is LONG overdue. I apologize to the person who sent this to me that I haven’t gotten it up sooner.

Part of what I...

Critique 49

I have basically this same image. So, even though this isn’t my image, the critique is as much for me as anyone else. It...

Critique 48

The photographer who sent this to me said:

“not the greatest light but cool subject.  Any help would be great”

I’d disagree on the light. I...

Critique 47

I am not a sports shooter. I don’t claim to be good at it or be able to critique a sports shot. I am,...

Critique 46

This is another image where everything is done right.  Miles Smith is another amazing photographer who comes on our His Light Workshop trips. I...

Critique 45

The dreaded HDR halo. My friend Jim Begley is the master of HDR. Fortunately for His Light Workshops, he’ll share that knowledge with you....

Critique 44

I like the artsy effect, but the white spots in the top of the frame keep leading my eye astray. I think overall it...