Critique 10

Posted on April 4th, by Snake in Critique. No Comments

Critique 10


This is a wow image: right time, right place, right light. A few things I’d adjust. I think a tighter crop would be better.

  1. This foreground is very bright and you eye goes here immediately. The subject should always be the brightest thing in your image. Rules are made to be broken. Sometimes you may think something in shadow or silhouette breaks the rule, but those things aren’t really the subject, the real subject is the light around them, a little mind blowing. This is not one of those cases. you want your eye to go straight to the osprey (I think).
  2. The green is WAY to green. I expect to see a leprechaun to pop out with a pot o’ gold, it’s that green.
  3. The background is a little to in focus. Hard to adjust in camera (unless you shoot birds for a living and know all the tricks).  You can use focal point or something similar to blur that up.

Here is cropped it down and make your eye focus on the bird. What a fantastic shot, bravo and thanks for sending it in!

Leave a Reply

The Critiques

Thank you to all who have submitted images.

Critique 50

This is LONG overdue. I apologize to the person who sent this to me that I haven’t gotten it up sooner.

Part of what I...

Critique 49

I have basically this same image. So, even though this isn’t my image, the critique is as much for me as anyone else. It...

Critique 48

The photographer who sent this to me said:

“not the greatest light but cool subject.  Any help would be great”

I’d disagree on the light. I...

Critique 47

I am not a sports shooter. I don’t claim to be good at it or be able to critique a sports shot. I am,...

Critique 46

This is another image where everything is done right.  Miles Smith is another amazing photographer who comes on our His Light Workshop trips. I...

Critique 45

The dreaded HDR halo. My friend Jim Begley is the master of HDR. Fortunately for His Light Workshops, he’ll share that knowledge with you....

Critique 44

I like the artsy effect, but the white spots in the top of the frame keep leading my eye astray. I think overall it...